TEXAS GOSPEL VOLUNTEER
Can a miracle happen in a world governed by natural laws? The Scottish philosopher David Hume (1711 to 1776), a famous skeptic, said no. In An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (Section X, Part I), he wrote, “A miracle is a violation of the laws of nature.” Because experience has firmly established those laws, he argued, the evidence against any miracle is overwhelming.
Well known mathematician John Lennex pointed out in an interview that Hume’s conclusion rests on a confusion about what the laws of nature are. Following Ludwig Wittgenstein, a twentieth-century Austrian philosopher of language, he argues that laws are descriptors, not causes. They summarize how nature usually behaves; they do not force anything to happen. So a miracle does not break a law, because a law was never a power that could be broken. It is simply an event outside the usual pattern.
He adds that Antony Flew, a prominent British philosopher who long championed atheism before embracing belief in God, told him Hume had erred. It was, he says, “a most interesting confession.”
The Bible tells us God does not answer to nature but sustains it. Colossians 1:17 (NASB) tells us, “He is before all things, and in Him all things hold together.” If God upholds the regularities we describe, He is free to act beyond them.
Hume’s argument is only as strong as his definition. If the definition fails, the case must be rebuilt.
This is what the Lord says: ‘If My covenant for day and night does not continue, and I have not established the fixed patterns of heaven and earth,
Jeremiah 33:25
